Skip to main content
Codex Mundi A scholarly atlas of the senses lost when crossing borders
Codex MundiKinesics — gesturesCrossed indexes (Latin America - enmity)
e0111Kinesics — gestures · designation

Crossed indexes (Latin America - enmity)

In Latin America (Mexico, Colombia, Venezuela, Central America...), crossing both index fingers in an X shape is said by some authors to mean enmity or a broken relationship. Claim not confirmed by independent open sources -- disputed local interpretation.

✓ Target directionSee description_long - regionalized emblematic gesture.
⚠ Interpreted meaningSee description_long - major geographical variations.

01The gesture and its expected meaning

Latin America (Mexico, Central America, Colombia, Venezuela, etc.). Gesture: both index fingers crossed to form a visible X (one index per hand), sometimes with a sharp movement or hostile look. Meaning: according to some authors (notably Axtell, 1998), this gesture would signal enmity, a broken relationship, or ill will -- but this specific claim has NOT been confirmed by independent open sources (2026 review); some Spanish-language sources instead describe crossed fingers in the region as meaning luck or hope, as in the West. Context: if the claim holds, occasional and informal, mostly among young people.

02Where it goes wrong: geography of misunderstanding

Non-Latinos may not recognize gesture. Potential confusion with neutral gesture. No major misunderstanding documented since gesture too regionalized. Serious misunderstanding possible if Latino index/major cross INTENTIONAL in non-latino direction unaware of meaning: possible relational tension without comprehensible cause.

03Historical genesis

Probably rooted in Latin superstition/misfortune traditions (cross = break in luck). Codification via Latin-American folk traditions. Axtell 1998 documentation. Persistence despite globalization; gesture remains a marker of Latin-American cultural identity.

04famous documented incidents

No international incidents. Probable anecdotes: misunderstandings in youth relations. Gesture too regionalized generation-specific.

05Practical recommendations

Never initiate towards non-Latinos or in a professional context. Never do: Signal direct hostility in Latin America. Relationship likely to break down. Alternatives:** Increased physical distance, verbal clarity, respectful silence.

Geography of misunderstanding

Neutral

  • mexico
  • guatemala
  • honduras
  • nicaragua
  • el-salvador
  • costa-rica
  • panama
  • cuba
  • dominican-republic
  • puerto-rico
  • brazil
  • argentina
  • chile
  • colombia
  • peru
  • venezuela
  • ecuador
  • uruguay
  • paraguay
  • bolivia

Not documented

  • peuples-autochtones
  • eu-occidentale

Practical recommendations

To do

  • Validation contextuelle. Privilégier oralité explicite en doute.

Avoid

  • Ne pas extrapoler d'une région à l'autre sans terrain.

Neutral alternatives

Sources · 2

AcademicGestures: The Do's and Taboos of Body Language Around the World —
ReferenceCrossed fingers —